| 2011 Music of the Night |
| 2010 Retrospective-Shakespeare Does Broadway |
2009 Wizard of Oz |
| 2008 Best Little Whorehouse in Texas |
2007 South Pacific |
| 2006 Annie |
2005 Oklahoma! |
| 2004 Anything Goes |
2003 Guys and Dolls |
| 2002 Carousel |
2001 How to Succeed in Business |
| 2000 Damn Yankees |
1999 Fiddler on the Roof |
| 1998 Hello, Dolly! |
1997 Cinderella |
| 1996 Annie Get Your Gun |
1995 The Music Man |
| 1994 Follies |
1993 The Pajama Game |
| 1992 Li’l Abner |
1991 Oklahoma! |
| 1990 Kiss Me Kate |
1989 Cabaret |
| 1988 The Boyfriend |
1987 Good News |
| 1986 Anything Goes |
1985 Damn Yankees |
| 1984 Guys and Dolls |
1983 The Music Man |
| 1982 South Pacific |
1981 Oklahoma! |
| 1980 Sweet Charity |
1979 No, No, Nanette |
| 1978 Mame |
1977 Irene |
| 1976 Anything Goes |
